The question is, how does this data gets in the hands of enforcement personnel?
One of the tough, unanswered questions about electronic logs for hours of service is how to give the roadside inspector access to the log.
The simplest solution is a cable hookup between the electronic onboard recorder that records the e-logs and the inspector’s laptop, and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is including that in its options. But wireless communications are more complicated, requiring agreement on issues such as security, protocols, interfaces and data display.
Just last month, after a meeting with carriers, enforcement officials and EOBR suppliers, the agency decided that the best way to address solve the wireless problem is to build a Web-based system for transmitting logs.
Details are sketchy at this point, but the agency is envisioning a system in which the EOBR transmits log data via satellite to the vendor’s server, and the officer accesses that data through another server set up and administered by the agency.
This week the agency asked its Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee, a panel of 19 officials from the industry, the enforcement community and labor and safety advocacy groups, to come up with recommendations on how to put such a system together.
Among the details to be clarified are how the EOBR can wirelessly identify and connect to external networks so the data can be transmitted, and how to establish a communications protocol that is both timely and secure, said Michael Huntley, chief of vehicle and roadside operations for the agency. Other issues have to do with the transmission of the data through telematics application services, USB connections and the 802.11wireless local area network.
There is considerable pressure to get these details worked out quickly. The agency has less than a year before it goes live with an eobr requirement that targets habitual hours of service violators. That rule, effective June 1, 2012, will force carriers that violate the rules 10 percent of the time to use the electronic devices.
At the committee’s meeting in Alexandria, Va., this week, FMCSA Senior Transportation Specialist Deborah Freund said the agency’s aim is to have all the details settled by then so that the industry can see exactly what the EOBR requirements will be in three to four years, when almost all carriers will have to use the devices.
New set of questions
There are other issues in play besides the technical questions the committee is studying.
One is cost. Randy Mullett, vice president of government relations and public affairs for Con-way, said carriers that have invested in GPS systems that are not hard-wired to the engine control module will have to retrofit their onboard devices with those connectors before they can install an electronic logging function. Con-way, which supports e-logs and is integrating them into its fleet, would have to rewire its devices at considerable expense in order to comply, he said.
The enforcement community also has concerns, since not all roadside inspectors have wireless capability and in any case would need a backup system if the network is down.
Mullett raised the possibility that this approach may change the agency’s cost analysis so much that it would have to reopen the rulemaking.
Huntley said much depends on what the advisory committee recommends. It is possible, he acknowledged, that there might have to be technical amendments or elements of the rule might have to be put back through the rulemaking process. Or it is possible that implementation might be delayed, although the agency’s objective is to finish on schedule, he said.
‘Different mousetraps’
Another complicating factor is that Congress has legislation that would mandate EOBRs on most trucks. A bill offered by Sens. Mark Pryor, D-Ark., and Lamar Alexander, R-Tenn., would give the Department of Transportation 18 months to come up with a final rule and an additional 18 months to put it into effect. This measure has the strong support of a group of trucking companies, the Alliance for Driver Safety and Security.
According to David Kraft, director of business development at Qualcomm Enterprise Services and chairman of the Technology and Maintenance Council’s EOBR Task Force, the bill contains language that would force the agency to make changes in its rule. It would require tougher language on tamper resistance, driver identification, data security and certification of EOBR devices, he said.
David Parker, senior legal counsel at Great West Casualty and the chairman of the committee, is aware of the potential problem.
“It is important not to have the House and Senate designing a totally different mousetrap,” he said.
Parker hopes that the committee will be able to come up with technical specifications that will satisfy everyone’s concerns. To that end he deputized seven members of the committee to meet with eobr vendors and equipment manufacturers to look into the matter and provide guidance.
The subcommittee will be chaired by Robert Powell of the Virginia State Police and will include Janice Mulanix of the California Highway Patrol, Thomas Jacques of the Pittsburgh Police, Rob Abbott of American Trucking Associations, Calvin Studivant, a driver for Community Coach, Jane Mathis of Parents Against Tired Truckers and Stephen Owings of Road Safe America. Also participating will be Greer Woodruff of J.B. Hunt, Parker said.
The subcommittee will meet in the Washington area in mid-July and early August, and will submit its recommendations to the full committee on August 29.
Printer Friendly Version
Email This Story
RSS
Government/Regulations: Related News
6/24/2011 – FMCSA Opts for Wireless Web-Based Transmission of Electronic Logs
One of the tough, unanswered questions about electronic logs for hours of service is how to give the roadside inspector access to the log.
The simplest solution is a cable hookup between the electronic onboard recorder that records the e-logs and the inspector’s laptop, and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is including that in its options. But wireless communications are more complicated, requiring agreement on issues such as security, protocols, interfaces and data display.
Just last month, after a meeting with carriers, enforcement officials and EOBR suppliers, the agency decided that the best way to address solve the wireless problem is to build a Web-based system for transmitting logs….
More
6/21/2011 – CARB Looking at More Changes to Reefer Rules
The California Air Resources Board will hold a third workshop to discuss potential changes to its existing Transport Refrigeration Unit regulation….
More
6/21/2011 – Oregon Governor Signs Idling Reduction Law
Oregon Gov. John Kitzhaber signed HB 2081, an idling reduction bill, into law on June 16. The new law means that trucks will not be allowed to idle more than five minutes in any 60 minute period, with some exceptions….
More
6/20/2011 – Deadline Nears for Flexible Compliance Option for California Trailer Regs
Large fleets that operate 53-foot box-type trailers in California are strongly advised to visit the California Air Resources Board website before July 1, 2011 to register their trailers and take advantage of the flexible phase-in option to comply with California’s Tractor-Trailer Greenhouse Gas regulation….
More
6/20/2011 – FMCSA Announces New Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee Members
The U.S. Department of Transportation’s Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration named five new members to its Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee….
More
6/17/2011 – EPA Proposes Tougher Guidelines for SCR Engines
The pollution control systems most engine manufacturers used to meet 2010 emission standards have been effective, but technical developments justify tougher guidelines, says the Environmental Protection Agency….
More
6/16/2011 – CVSA Urges Congress to Lift Ban on Enroute Bus Inspections, Look at Bus Driver HOS Regs
The Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance urged Congress to lift the current restriction in the law that prohibits enroute bus inspections and pledged to immediately encourage all state members to take aggressive enforcement action when warranted….
More
6/15/2011 – ATA Seeks Withdrawal of Hazardous Materials Loading and Unloading Proposal
In comments filed with the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, American Trucking Associations asked the agency to withdraw its proposal to regulate the loading and unloading of hazardous materials in order to conduct needed research….
More
6/15/2011 – FMCSA Wants to Extend Paper Medical Certificate Requirement
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration wants extend the requirement that truck drivers keep a paper copy of their medical certificate with them when they’re on the job.
That requirement was supposed to end in 2012 when a new reporting system is scheduled to be in place, but in a proposed rule published yesterday, the agency said it wants the requirement to stay in place until January 30, 2014….
More
6/10/2011 – Federal HOS Research Studies Flawed, ATA, NIT League Charge
Research into driver fatigue that federal authorities recently added to the hours of service docket is faulty and should not be used to make policy changes to the hours rule, the American Trucking Associations charged….
More
6/9/2011 – Illinois Attempts to Improve Truck Routing Information
Truck drivers who plot their routes with consumer GPS devices may be setting themselves up for a problem. Those systems are great for showing car drivers which way to turn, but they don’t necessarily identify critical truck information, such as the height of a bridge or the weight limit on a county road….
More
6/8/2011 – FMCSA Proposes Dropping Inspection Reports on Defect-Free Container Chassis
Drayage drivers would not have to fill out and file a vehicle inspection report for container chassis that have no apparent defects, according to a rules change proposed by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration….
More
6/1/2011 – Industry Groups Challenge Provision of New Licensing Rule
A coalition of industry groups is challenging a provision of the recent federal rule that sets tough new testing standards for commercial licenses.
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration rule, posted last month, contains a provision that prohibits third parties from administering skills tests to the applicants they have trained. The agency put in the prohibition as protection against a possible conflict of interest arising from a trainer at a commercial training school also acting as a state-certified test examiner.
But the industry coalition, in a petition filed yesterday at the agency, said this will cause problems for the industry and the states….
More
5/26/2011 – Oregon Brake Bill Fades Away
An Oregon bill that would have required the elimination of copper in motor vehicle brakes won’t go any further this session….
More
5/20/2011 – Canadian Group Urges CVSA to Count “Screen/Triage” Inspections
The Canadian Trucking Alliance urged the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance to record ‘screen’ or ‘triage’ inspections on a carrier’s profile….
More
5/20/2011 – Champions of Change Roundtable Discusses Transportation Issues
The White House kicked off National Transportation Week on Monday, May 16, with a ‘Champions of Change’ roundtable discussion about transportation issues….
More
5/19/2011 – ATA Opposes Efforts to Regulate Detention Time
The American Trucking Associations says detention time is an issue to be negotiated between carriers and shippers, and the federal government should stay out of it….
More
5/13/2011 – FEMA Introduces Cellphone Emergency Alert System
The Federal Emergency Management Agency announced a text message-based emergency alert system for enabled mobile devices….
More
5/13/2011 – Rockefeller Wades into Fight Over Mexico Pilot Project
Sen. John Rockefeller is taking the Obama administration to task over its plan to restart long-distance trucking across the Mexican border.
In a letter yesterday to Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood and U.S. Trade Representative Ron Kirk, the West Virginia Democrat said the administration’s pilot program will endanger U.S. companies’ competitiveness….
More
5/13/2011 – FMCSA Considering Using DataQ’s to Transmit Crash Accountability Information
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is considering using its CSA data correction system to gather information about a carrier’s accountability in the event of an accident.
The agency’s DataQ’s system, which carriers use now to correct mistakes that have gotten into their CSA scores, could be used by carriers to provide a police accident report that shows accountability, said senior transportation specialist Bryan Price at a forum hosted by the National Transportation Safety Board this week….
More
5/12/2011 – New Version of Jason’s Law Revised to Appeal to New Congress
U.S. Reps Paul Tonko (D-NY) and Erik Paulsen (R-MN) have introduced a revised version of Jason’s Law, which would create a grant program to help alleviate the parking shortages and pay for safety improvements at existing rest areas….
More
5/11/2011 – FMCSA Enhances Public Access With Searchable Database
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has launched a new web page that improves free public access to orders and decisions on FMCSA civil penalty and safety rating cases….
More
5/10/2011 – CV Safety Technology Bill Would Offer Incentives for Safety Technology
Two U.S. representatives have introduced a bill that would provide a tax credit for commercial vehicle owners to purchase and install specific advanced safety technology, including brake stroke monitoring systems, vehicle stability systems, lane departure warning systems and collision warning or mitigation systems….
More