Skip to content

Watchdog Agency Offers Course Correction on CSA

By Oliver B. Patton, Washington Editor

The CSA truck safety enforcement program is missing pieces and is behind schedule, so it’s too soon to tell how effective it will be, but data gathered so far suggests that it will be an improvement over the old enforcement system, says the Government Accountability Office.

In its 52-page assessment of CSA, the watchdog agency acknowledges the successes of the fledgling program but tells the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration that it needs to finish work on the big missing piece: the rulemaking to establish carrier safety fitness ratings.

The proposed safety fitness rule, now more than four years in the making, is scheduled to be published in February. It is not likely to be finished until 2013.

“Data from a pilot test suggest that (the CSA Safety Management System) and the expanded range of intervention tools provides a more effective means of contacting …carriers and addressing their safety issue,” GAO said.

But GAO also homed in on an issue that is likely to remain a long-term shortcoming: Not all carriers pass through the inspection process frequently enough to generate data for the system.

“Small carriers are less likely to receive enough roadside inspections to be scored and ranked in SMS,” GAO said, referencing data that shows a marked drop-off in sufficient data based on the size of the carrier.

For instance: while fleets ranging from 16 to 500 or more trucks have data sufficiency above 50%, those with 6 to 15 trucks have just 28% and those with five or fewer have less than 6%.

Another shortcoming, GAO said, is that the safety agency has not kept Congress and the public well enough informed on the progress of CSA. The agency needs to regularly report to Congress on CSA problems and delays, GAO said.

The safety agency has focused so far on carrier safety ratings but needs to step up work on driver fitness, GAO said.

One reason for this is the agency’s concern about having the authority to sideline drivers who are found to be unfit, based on their ratings. To solve that problem, the agency will seek an amendment to the current transportation law when it is revised, perhaps next year.

In its response to the GAO, the safety agency said it intends to pursue the driver fitness program.

For a copy of the report, go to

Printer Friendly Version
Email This Story
Bookmark and Share

Government/Regulations: Related News

10/4/2011 – Watchdog Agency Offers Course Correction on CSA

The CSA truck safety enforcement program is missing pieces and is behind schedule, so it’s too soon to tell how effective it will be, but data gathered so far suggests that it will be an improvement over the old enforcement system, says the Government Accountability Office….

9/29/2011 – USDA to Pay Biofuel Producers in 41 States

The U.S. Department of Agriculture will make payments to more than 160 energy producers in 41 states to support the production and expansion of advanced biofuels such as biodiesel….

9/28/2011 – Mica Says He Will Challenge Any Changes to Hours Rule

Rep. John Mica, chairman of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, warned President Obama that he will challenge any changes to the current hours of service rules.

“We will aggressively oversee any attempt by the U.S. Department of Transportation to impose new regulatory burdens on the trucking industry by making changes to the current hours of service rules,” Mica and three fellow Republicans wrote in a Sept. 23 letter to the president….

9/27/2011 – Appeals Court Strikes LA Port’s Employee Requirement

The American Trucking Associations won a reversal of a key piece of the Port of Los Angeles concession program for drayage carriers.

In a ruling yesterday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit threw out the LA port’s plan to force independent drivers to become employees of drayage companies. The court upheld several other aspects of the concession program, covering issues such as off-street parking, maintenance and financial capability….

9/27/2011 – CARB Fines Businesses for Air Quality Violations

California’s Air Resources Board settled 37 cases of air quality violations during the second quarter, mostly by trucks and buses for failure to properly conduct and pass self-inspections aimed at measuring vehicle smoke emissions to ensure state requirements are met….

9/23/2011 – Court Tells Minnesota State Patrol to Stop Violating Truckers’ Rights

A judge has issued orders telling the Minnesota State Patrol how to change its practices in order to stop violating truckers’ Fourth Amendment rights with its fatigue enforcement program….

9/21/2011 – Measure Would Allow Heavier Trucks on Maine, Vermont Interstates

Maine and Vermont senators have won preliminary approval of a measure to permanently allow 100,000-pound trucks on state interstates.

The measure, pushed by Sen. Patrick Leahy of Vermont and Sen. Susan Collins of Maine, was included in the annual transportation funding bill that the Senate Transportation Appropriations Subcommittee approved Tuesday….

9/16/2011 – Congress Clears Highway Program Extension

The Senate yesterday approved, 92 to 6, a measure that will extend the current highway program through next March, clearing the way for final passage….

9/14/2011 – NTSB Recommends Trucker Cellphone Ban in Wake of Kentucky Accident

The National Transportation Safety Board recommended banning mobile phone use by commercial drivers Tuesday following its investigation of 2010 cross-median truck crash that claimed 11 lives….

9/14/2011 – NHTSA Rejects Petition to Amend Antilock Brake Rule

Rising to the defense of the heavy truck antilock brake requirement, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration last week rejected a petition to drop the standard or give drivers the option not to use it….

9/13/2011 – Congress to Take Up 6-Month Highway Extension

Congress is considering a clean six-month extension of the federal highway program, which would fund the program at its current level until March 31, 2012.

The House bill, introduced by Rep. John Mica, R-Fla., chairman of the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, will be taken up this week, according to a schedule posted by the Rules Committee….

9/9/2011 – FMCSA Still Working on Mexico Pilot Details

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has more work to do before it can start the pilot program for long-distance trucking across the Mexican border.

The Inspector General of the Department of Transportation says the agency has met most of the congressional requirements for the pilot program, but still must explain how it will conduct pre-authorization safety audits of Mexican carriers in Mexico….

9/9/2011 – Right to Repair Supporters Drive for Mass. Ballot Placement

Following certification by the Massachusetts Attorney General of its proposed ballot question, the Right to Repair Coalition will immediately begin collecting signatures to place the issue before state voters….

9/8/2011 – Congress Considering Extension of Highway Program

With less than a month until the federal highway program expires, it looks as though Congress may muddle through with yet another extension – the eighth short-term continuation since the program expired September 2009….

9/6/2011 – FMCSA Rules Port Sticker Not Preempted

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has ruled that the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey can continue to ask motor carriers to put stickers on trucks entering its facilities indicating that they are in the Drayage Truck Registry….

9/1/2011 – Texas DOT Launches New Overweight Load Permitting System

The Texas Department of Transportation launched the Texas Permitting Routing Optimization System, TxPROS, Aug. 30 for overweight and oversized loads….

9/1/2011 – EOBR Details Complex and Messy

It turns out that a rule requiring electronic onboard recorders to track hours of service is not a simple thing. Take the question of how the inspecting officer will read the driver’s log information off of the machine….

8/31/2011 – DOT Proposes to Eliminate Deadlines for Replacing Traffic Signs

The Obama Administration is eliminating dozens of burdensome regulations on traffic signs, which cash-strapped state and local governments expect will save them millions of dollars….

8/31/2011 – FMCSA Awards Over $2 Million for Truck Safety in South Dakota

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced over $2 million in federal grants to improve commercial truck and bus safety in North Dakota….

8/31/2011 – Advisory Panel Will Take More Time on EOBR Recommendations

It is too soon to gauge the impact of last week’s court ruling on the electronic onboard recorder rule, but David Parker, chairman of the Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee, sees it as an opportunity….

8/30/2011 – Chain Law Starts Sept. 1 on Colorado’s I-70

Starting Sept. 1, all commercial vehicles traveling on I-70 in Colorado between milepost 133 (Edwards exit) and milepost 259 (Morrison exit) must carry sufficient chains to be in compliance with the Colorado chain law….

8/29/2011 – EOBR Implementation Tops Advisory Committee Agenda

UPDATED — Key technical details of the pending electronic onboard recorder mandate are scheduled to be discussed this week at a meeting of the Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee. At the request of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, the committee has been looking into issues such as how best to give roadside inspectors access to electronic logs….

8/29/2011 – Court Rejects EOBR Rule

A federal appeals court Friday tossed out the electronic onboard recorder rule, saying it does not do enough to prevent harassment of drivers.

In response to a petition by several independent drivers and the Owner-Operator Independent Driver Association, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit vacated the rule and sent it back to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration for review….

8/26/2011 – Texas Simplifies Vehicle Registration Fee Structure

A new system that standardizes and simplifies registration fees for nearly every vehicle owner in Texas begins September 1….

8/26/2011 – DOT to Revise Dozens of Regulations

The Department of Transportation is eliminating or revising dozens of rules in response to President Obama’s call for a review of burdensome regulations….

8/26/2011 – Pennsylvania Gets $8 Million for Truck and Bus Safety

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced more than $8 million in federal grants to improve commercial truck and bus safety across the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania….

8/23/2011 – FMCSA Redefines Hazardous Materials Threshold

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration changed criteria for the Hazardous Materials intervention threshold.

In the August 3 Safety Measurement System release, FMCSA refined the criteria that determines which motor carriers are subject to the more stringent Hazardous Materials intervention threshold. …

8/23/2011 – New Illinois Law to Improve Oversize/Overweight Permits

Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn signed legislation allowing the state Department of Transportation to issue permits for loads that previously exceeded size and weight restrictions for travel on state highways if specific conditions are met….

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )
Join over 3.000 visitors who are receiving our newsletter and learn how to optimize your blog for search engines, find free traffic, and monetize your website.
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.
Tax, Accounting, Consulting - Emil Estafanous, CPA, CFF, CGMA